A guide for owners

How much is a Frank Tenney Johnson painting worth?

Frank Tenney Johnson is remembered for cowboys and horses under the moon, but he also painted the West by day, illustrated Zane Grey's novels, and spent his last summers painting Yellowstone country. Which kind of Johnson you own is the first question in judging its value.

Frank Tenney Johnson (1874–1939) grew up on an Iowa farm beside the Overland Trail, studied in Milwaukee and New York, and in 1904 made a painting trip to Colorado and New Mexico that gave him his trademark subject: life carried on by moonlight. He was much in demand as an illustrator until about 1923, when his easel paintings began to sell well and he gave up illustration. He settled in Alhambra, California, became a full National Academician in 1937, and spent the summers of 1931 to 1938 near Cody, Wyoming.

What decides the value of a Frank Tenney Johnson

Subject

Painting, illustration and size

Johnson worked from small oil studies to large exhibition canvases, on canvas and on board, and produced illustrations for magazines and books for many years. Easel paintings and illustration art are judged differently, and size and finish count within each. Measure the image itself, not the frame.

Period and quality

An inscription, date or label helps place a work: illustration in Milwaukee and New York from the late 1890s; the 1904 trip West; the New York years as illustrator and exhibitor; Southern California from the 1920s; and the Cody summers of the 1930s. After he became a full Academician in 1937 he signed his paintings with "N.A." In any period, the quality of the light, above all in the night scenes, is what sets his best work apart.

Condition

Check for flaking, tears, relining, overpaint and darkened varnish, which is especially distorting in a dark night scene. Johnson built up texture with brush, palette knife and even his fingers, so look for cracks in thicker passages. Leave any treatment to a conservator, after advice.

Labels and provenance

Exhibition labels from the National Academy of Design or the Salmagundi Club, gallery labels such as those of the Stendahl Galleries in Los Angeles, inscriptions and family records all strengthen a Johnson's history. Photograph the whole back.

Signature and authenticity

Johnson's paintings and illustrations were widely reproduced, and Western pictures are sometimes misattributed. Signature, technique, materials and documented history are weighed together. Steven Stern Fine Arts can usually say from photographs whether a picture merits closer study.

Why we don't publish prices

Steven Stern Fine Arts does not post prices for Frank Tenney Johnson, and this page deliberately contains none. Any number given before the painting has been seen would be a guess, and a guess can lead an owner to sell for too little or to hold out for a figure no buyer will pay. Every Johnson is judged on its own merits, once we have photographs, measurements and whatever you know of its history.

Having your Johnson looked at

Everything needed for a first look can be done at home:

Send these through the seller inquiry form or to StevenSternFineArts@gmail.com. If you would rather talk first, call Steven Stern Fine Arts at (310) 570-5679. The gallery's past sales of Johnson paintings show the range of work it has handled.

Your options for selling a Johnson

Owners usually choose one of three routes with the gallery. Steven Stern Fine Arts can buy the painting outright, which is quick and private. It can take the painting on consignment and offer it to collectors it already knows, paying you when it sells. Or, for an important painting or a whole estate, it can arrange a private sale and advise you along the way. Your name, the buyer's name and the price stay confidential.

Common questions

My Johnson is signed with "N.A." after the name. What does that mean?
N.A. stands for National Academician. Johnson became a full member of the National Academy of Design in 1937 and signed his paintings that way afterwards, which helps date them.
Is a Johnson illustration of interest?
Yes. Original illustration art is collected, though it is judged differently from easel paintings. Tell us where it was published if you know.
Is a daytime scene by Johnson less desirable than a night scene?
His night scenes are the best known, but strong daytime pictures have their own collectors. Each painting is judged on its own quality.
How can I tell an original from a print?
His paintings were widely reproduced as prints and in magazines. A photograph of the surface taken at an angle under strong light usually shows brushwork; send one.

More answers for owners are on the Frank Tenney Johnson seller FAQ. For Johnson's life and career, read the Frank Tenney Johnson biography.

Sources

Written for this site by Steven Stern Fine Arts. Facts about the artist were checked against the sources below; nothing here is a valuation of any particular painting.

  1. Jean Stern, "Artists in Santa Catalina Island Before 1945" (section on Frank Tenney Johnson), Resource Library, Traditional Fine Arts Organization. tfaoi.org (accessed October 2026).
  2. National Academy of Design, "Frank Tenney Johnson." nationalacademy.emuseum.com (accessed October 2026).
  3. Buffalo Bill Center of the West, "Frank Tenney Johnson: a fatal kiss," June 14, 2015. centerofthewest.org.
  4. Buffalo Bill Center of the West, "The Draw of Cody," Points West, June 30, 2022. centerofthewest.org.
  5. Eiteljorg Museum, "Frank Tenney Johnson." collections.eiteljorg.org (accessed October 2026).
  6. Wikipedia, "Frank Tenney Johnson." en.wikipedia.org (accessed October 2026).
  7. Getty Research Institute, Union List of Artist Names, "Johnson, Frank Tenney." vocab.getty.edu (accessed October 2026).
  8. Steven Stern Fine Arts, Frank Tenney Johnson paintings sold (title and date only).

Own a Frank Tenney Johnson?

A cowboy under a full moon, riders on a starlit trail, a Yellowstone landscape or an illustration for a Zane Grey novel: send us a few photographs of the painting, its back and its signature, and we will take it from there.